BarraCuda Pro 10TB mtc1 - Seagate 12TB BarraCuda Pro Review
Multi-tier Caching Technology (MCT for short) is the umbrella term that Seagate has come up with to explain all the various enhancements they have crafted for hard disk drives they obtained from the SandForce IP when they purchased this division from LSI a few years back. Yes, it has taken Seagate that long to modify and tweak as hard drive and solid-state storage is radically different. Beyond taking their time to get it right this is a combination of algorithms and other low-level enhancements that allow for a radically different approach to a hard drive’s controller and its caching.
The easiest way to imagine the old way of how things were done was to imagine the controller and onboard cache as a secretary and a filing cabinet. As the secretary gained experience with her job she would ‘preload’ certain files into this cabinet for quicker turn arounds when their boss asked “give me X file”. It worked, but even adding in extra cores (a second secretary in this analogy) and bigger filing cabinet the end result was as many misses as hits – as the extra cache was barely able to improve the chances of the data being in the ‘filing cabinet’. To extended this analogy imagine the times when they guessed wrong as having to go into the backroom of the office and dig up the ‘proper file’.
BarraCuda Pro 10TB layers - Seagate 12TB BarraCuda Pro Review
MCT on the other hand is best considered a marriage of Seagate’s previous Solid-State Hybrid Drives with their Hard-Disk Drive lines… just without the need of expansive – and relatively short lived – NAND. Basically, just like a SSHD, sans downsides of cost and lifespan, MCT allows the ‘secretary’ the luxury of making multiple branch predictions and storing all these possibilities in their on hand ‘filing cabinet’. Not only does this increase the hit ratio it allows the ‘secretary’ the luxury of actually being able to properly use the entire filing cabinet – and making the filing cabinet even larger makes the secretary even more efficient. This is why, unlike previous predictive caching algorithms, using a massive 256MB cache buffer actually makes sense – and going even bigger would potentially net even better results.
BarraCuda Pro 10TB mtc - Seagate 12TB BarraCuda Pro Review
As these algorithms are based on extremely advanced multi-branch prediction math, they can also be tuned for various scenarios. While yes earlier generation’s algorithms could also be somewhat tweaked, MCT was built from the ground up to be highly versatile. In their research – and a big reason why it has taken years to accomplish – Seagate identified numerous areas that noticeably impact real world performance. Equally important, each of these impact different scenarios in unique ways and each of them required slightly different (or even radically different) math to predict future needs. In a perfect world you could simply use a super-computer and a couple GB of ram cache to boost all of them all the time and create the perfect all-round model capable of handling any task or any scenario with near perfect efficiency.
That obviously is not possible with hard drive storage, so after Seagate identified these areas, they then spent the time and effort classifying how these areas are used in the real world. For instance, a HDD placed into a NAS is going to have more ‘large file’ random read/write IO requests than say a HDD in a home users system; whereas an OS or even secondary storage drive will need small(er) file sequential and random performance boosted. With this information now available to Seagate engineer’s they can with very little effort tweak how much priority each of these underlying algorithms need, hardcode that into the firmware of a given model… and go from there. Yes this boosting of certain algorithms (or to be more precise giving them higher processor cycle and cache storage priority) means it comes at the expense of other areas, but tailor made performance means as long as you choose the right model the ‘real world’ performance for your needs will be higher than ever before.
BarraCuda Pro 10TB seg - Seagate 12TB BarraCuda Pro Review
This is also why when you purchase a Seagate Guardian series drive with retail packaging you will notice a different MCT logo on the front of the box and the drive. For example, the Seagate BarraCuda models come with the word ‘compute’ in bold prominence. Whereas on an IronWolf it will be “NAS”. Once you understand what the ‘code name’ or branding means, picking the proper model becomes a lot more straightforward than trying to remember a color – like Western Digital does. This is an extremely elegant solution to conveying a rather complex subject in such a manner that even a novice buyer will almost instantly ‘get it’.